GRA8254 Management of IT, Fall 2008
[What's new] [Course overview] [Administrivia][Detailed seminar plan: 1 | 2
| 3 | 4
| 5 | 6
| 7 | 8
| 9]
[Prof's home
page]
[Prior courses 1997 | 1998 | 1999
| 2000 | 2001
| 2002 | 2003
| 2004 | 2005
|
2006 | 2007]
This is the home page for the MBA course GRA8254 Management
of IT.
The page is the primary communications vehicle for the course,
containing all
information necessary to participate, with the exception of literature
which is either provided on paper or in Blackboard. Comments to Espen via email.
What's New?
- October 21: Some more detail on the final assignment presentation.
- October 14: Finalized the final case (Pfizer virtual CIO)
- October 14: Changed timing of class Oct. 20.
- October 9: Changed various aspects - literature, assignment - of lectures later in October.
- October 6: Corrected text for the assignment for October 13: It is an individual assignment.
- October 2: Moved IT & economics lecture to the 13th from the 6th. Changed the order of some of the latter classes.
- September 19: Changed the order of class 5 (Linpro) and 6 (Value shops).
- September 16: Changed from one assignment each class to "some classes".
- September 4: Changed to the Schibsted case for lecture 2.
- June 18: Timings for individual lectures entered.
- June 17, 2008: Inital page based on last year,
archived
old page.
- NOTE: If you are or plan to be a participant in this
course, please read the opening
memo to students.
- The right to
make changes at any time is most explicitly reserved!!
Course overview
Thanks to the relentless increase in computer performance (often
referred to as Moore's
Law,)
information technology is increasingly pervasive in all aspects of
business or public administration: IT has a significant portion of all
investments (frequently, information system investements are second
only to housing); many of the most difficult decisions (strategic or
administrative) to be taken by managers involve information technology,
both as medium and content; and many actions (both external and
external to the organization) are carried out in information
technology, sometimes (for companies in hypercompetitive industries)
directly, to steal a march on the competition. The Internet floodwave
signals the beginning of an era where most markets will be electronic,
and, consequently, competition international.
The intent of this course is to give the student an
understanding of
the role of information technology in organizations, the impact of the
rapid technology evolution for business environments, and the challenge
of managing the technology (and the organizational units charged with
its introduction and support). The discussions will be within three
main areas:
- Managing IT for competitive advantage:
Understanding how IT can give the organization a competitive advantage,
and how to sustain that advantage.
- Understanding the role of IT in organizations:
This part
of the course will analyze organizations in terms of the chains, shops,
networks framework, trying to understand how value is created in each
of these strategic configurations, and how IT supports this value
creation.
- Managing the IT resource: Understanding
the organizational
challenges of IT management, the interface between IS and the business,
governance models and organizational processes, systems development and
delivery, outsourcing.
Administrivia
Use of computers
Extensive use of computers and the Internet is an integral activity of
the course: Handouts, messages, discussions, most of the literature and
some of the hand-ins will be done electronically. All communication
between professor and students outside the classroom will at least
initially be electronically.
Students are presumed to have a working knowledge of personal
information technology, as well as a reasonable understanding of the
different types of information technology (mainframe computers,
personal computers, data networks etc.) and applications (transaction
systems, data bases, decision support systems, electronic mail and
groupware) in a modern organization, such as would be expected from
someone who has worked in an organization using these tools for some
years. If you as a student feel you lack this knowledge,
please
take a look at the literature below - some of the books are quite good
beginners' guides to the technology and the vocabulary.
Literature
The main book of the course is
Pearlson, K. E. and C. S. Saunders (2006). Managing and using information
systems: A strategic approach,
Wiley. (hereafter referred to as P&S). This book manages to be
both
brief, strategically oriented, technically adept, yet written so that
it
does not go stale as fast as most other IT books. Quite the thing to
keep on the bookshelf when the MBA program is over and you
encounter real
IT managment problems.
If you need to look up technical words and concepts, I recommend the Wikipedia, which is
excellent on technical topics - but since it is a community-written
encyclopædia, caveat emptor applies.
For those interested in the economic laws underlying the current
Internet revolution, try Shapiro & Varian's Information Rules.
This book will be compulsory in a later elective
course on electronic strategic business development. For the
technologically challenged, books and texts are almost
too numerous to mention. No real recommendations
here.
For any other book, well - try my favorite books
page or book posts on my
blog.
Class preparation
Each class will have at least one case, as well as some reading
(articles and/or book chapters) associated with it. All material
(except HBS cases) will be found in Blackboard unless a) it is handed
out in class (normally, cases and some articles), or b) it is a
recommended book, or c) the article is available on the web, in which
case a link is provided from the course page. You are expected to
prepare for each class by reading the assigned material, using the
study questions to guide you if you wish. For some classes, you
are
expected to answer one specific question, and delivering the assignment
in Blackboard before 20:00 (8pm) the day before class. The
answer to the assignment question should be short (no more than 200
words), I am looking for keywords, not filler. The
assigned material, as well as the answers sent in by the students, will
then be discussed in class.
Classroom discussion
This course is taught by the
case method
- so classroom discussion is the main interaction between
teacher and students. It is crucial both for the students'
understanding and the quality of the discussion that the students are
intimately familiar with the contents of the case before the lecture
begins. Although individual time required to analyze cases varies
significantly, experience suggests that students should plan to spend at
the very least
two hours (more, if lacking in English language skills, business or
computer experience) on reading and analyzing each case (exclusive of
articles and other course reading), and prepare extensive notes of
their analysis to guide them in their discussion. The cases will be
accompanied by study questions, which provide guidance in analyzing the
case. The articles or book chapters may also help in analysing a case,
as well as discussions with your peers.
Grading
will be based on the following criteria:
- Individual participation (50% of grade)
will be based
mainly on the individual student's contribution in the classroom
discussion, with the weekly individual electronic hand-ins forming a
(small) part. Participation will be graded individually.
- Two group papers will be submitted
during the course. The first paper counts for 20% of the
total grade, the second for 30%.
- The first paper should be one of the following:
- Pick one of the following cases:
Dell, Glamox, Pacific Pride, and prepare a 7-12 page report
in the form of a memorandum to the main protagonist or protagonists
advising on what IS and managerial decisions will be key in the next
two years (based on the timing and facts of the case, not the company
as it is now) and what he or she should do about them.
- Answer the following question: You are CEO of a mid-range
manufacturing company (i.e. in the InformationWeek sample).
How
much money should you spend on information technology, and why? (7-12
pages)
- The second assignment should be done by all groups before
the last class:
- Read the case Pfizer's
Virtual CIO (HBS 9-305-018). You have been charged by the
ITLT to write a short report analyzing issue 4 on their agenda, where
it says "ITLT served as a template for how Pfizer organized IT
Activities across business groups. With the addition of Pharmacia, and
the resulting increase in company size and differences in IT processes
and systems, it was not clear if the ITLT model for organizing IT would
continue to be effective." Analyze the IT organization of Pfizer in
terms of its ability to address the issues IT pose to the company, and
give recommendations for how to change IT organization, if necessary.
Deadline: Before class starts, Thursday Oct. 30.
A tip about case preparation: Normally, it is not very useful to try to
find extra information about the company (more than what is in the
case). It can, however, sometimes help to look for overall
information about the industry and/or the technology - but don't overdo
it!
Each paper is due before class on the day the case is to be
taught
(submitted in Blackboard and on paper to the teacher). A grade will be
given within three days. Groups that are not satisfied with the grade
of the first assignment have the option to write another (from the
list) and pick the best one.
Detailed seminar
plan
The
class is divided into 18 modules, half of them double modules. The
right to make changes at any time is most explicitly reserved....
Material is in Blackboard
unless otherwise noted.
Class 0: Case teaching and
preparation (September 4, 1400-1600)
What is this case stuff, anyway? How can I survive and get
the
most out of a case-based course? Since case teaching is rather
unfamiliar to many students, we will take an hour to discuss what case
teaching means and how to prepare for it.
Preparatory reading:
Class
1: The evolution and role of IT in business
September 10, 9-1030
Introduction, course overview, work processes, administrivia, course
objectives. What difference does IT make?
Read and be prepared to discuss:
- Chapter 1 and 3 in P&S (plus the introduction, if
you haven't read it.)
- Sherman, Stratford P. (1984). Microsoft's drive to dominate
software. Fortune, January 23, 82-90.
- Malone, T. W., & Rockart, J. F. (1991). Computers,
Networks and the Corporation. Scientific American (September),
128-136.
- Leavitt, H. J., & Whisler, T. L. (1958). Management
in the 1980's. Harvard Business Review (November-December),
41-49.
- Case: Mrs. Field's Cookies (HBS
9-189-056) (Incidentally, here is a neat
little article on what it was like to work in this company in
1990.)
Further reading (for the especially interested):
- Coase,
R. H. (1937). “The Nature of the Firm.” Economica
4:
386-405. (Classic on the concept of transaction costs and the theory of
why firms exist and evolve. 25 pages, no formulas, got Coase the Nobel
Prize)
In your spare time:
Study questions:
- What are Malone & Rockart's key arguments? To what
extent were they right? Wrong?
- What role does information technology play at Mrs. Fields?
- What roles and responsibilities do the managers (i.e.,
Debbie
Fields, the controllers, the line managers, and the store managers)
have?
- Would you like to be a store manager for Mrs. Fields? Why?
Why not?
- What was computing technology like when Leavitt &
Whisler
wrote their article? What technological and organizational developments
did they foresee and which did they miss?
- Which parts of Microsoft's strategy worked - and which
didn't?
Assignment (to delivered in Blackboard):
Write 10 lines on my previous experience of using or managing
IT in organizations and 10 lines on what I expect
to get out of this course.
Class 2: The competitive impact of the Internet
September 10, 1030-1200
How should a traditional company meet the challenge of the Internet?
The news and media industry is facing challenges from Internet-enabled
companies, but has so far been successful in managing the transition.
What is the reason for their success - and will they be able to keep it
up?
Read and be prepared to discuss:
Further reading (for the especially interested):
- "More media, less news", The Economist, August 24, 2006 (In Blackboard).
In your spare time:
- Neal Stephenson (1999): Cryptonomicon.
Excellent novel about business startups, cryptography, computer
networks, the second world war, and much much more. Just the thing to
understand techies and technologies.
Study questions:
- What is the ownership structure of Schibsted – and what are the implications of it for their strategic outlook?
- Visit the web sites sesam.no/nyheter and google.no
(and click on “Nyheter” in the top right area of the
screen.) What are the implications for Schibsted of these types of
services?
- How does Google’s business model differ from
Schibsted’s? (note for exhibit 29: Google owns youtube.com and
blogger.com. Microsoft owns msn.com, live.com and msn.no. Yahoo owns
yahoo.com and flickr.com. Schibsted, in addition to the sites marked,
owns nettby.no)
- Should Aamodt allow Sesam to crawl (collect information) from Finn.no?
- Is the free-sheet business a sustainable market? Why hasn’t it been successful in Norway?
- What implications do the last statement – about the
cathedral or stock market approach – have for Schibsted’s
future?
Class 3: IT in Value
Chains
September 17, 0900-1030
Understanding the role of IT in value chain companies -- value chain
integration, parameterization, customer interface.
Read
and be prepared to discuss:
- Chapter 2 and 5 in P&S.
- Porter, M. E., & Millar, V. E. (1985). How
information gives you competitive advantage. Harvard Business
Review(July-August), 149-160.
- Fjeldstad, Ø. and E. Andersen (2003). "Casting
off the chains: Value shops and value networks." European Business Forum
(14): 47-53.
- Magretta, J. (1998). "The Power of Virtual Integration: An
Interview with Dell Computer's Michael Dell." Harvard Business Review
(March-April): 72-84.
- Case: Matching Dell (HBS 9-799-158).
- Friedman, Thomas (2005): "How a Dell Computer is built",
excerpt from chapter 12 in The
World is Flat.
Further reading (for the especially interested):
- Stabell, C. B. and Ø. D. Fjeldstad (1998).
“Configuring Value for Competitive Advantage: On Chains,
Shops
and Networks.” Strategic Management Journal 19:
413-437. (This is the more academic article forming the basis of the
"Casting off the chains" article above.)
- Clark, K. B. and T. Fujimoto (1991). Product
Development Performance - Strategy, Organization, and
Management in the World Auto Industry.
Boston, MA, Harvard Business School Press. Large study of product and
process development in the global auto industry. Food for
thought, many good concepts of organization and process.
- Utterback, J. M. (1994). Mastering
the Dynamics of Innovation. Boston, MA, Harvard
Business School Press. Technology innovation and how it works.
- Christensen,
C. M. (1997). The
Innovator's Dilemma: Why New Technologies Cause Great Firms to Fail.
Boston, MA, Harvard Business School Press. Seminal work on
the
interactions between technology innovation and market dominance.
- Iansiti, M. (1998). Technology
Integration: Making Critical Choices in a Dynamic World.
Boston, MA, Harvard Business School Press. Study of project
performance and technology conceptualization.
- Davenport, T. H. (1998). “Putting the Enterprise
into the Enterprise System.” Harvard Business
Review (July-August): 121-131.
Study questions:
- Dell's Direct model is widely admired, and many companies
have wanted
to emulate it. What competitive advantages does the business model
give compared to traditional retail distribution models?
- Why isn't Dell's business model more
widely used outside the personal computer business?
- What technology is typically used at each of Venkatraman's
five
stages? How has companies' ability to progress up these stages changed
with the technology?
- According to Porter & Millar, what can IT do for
the competitive power of a value chain?
- Porter and Millar's article is 18 years old--what parts are
it still applicable, what doesn't work anymore?
Class
4: Value chain
transformation: The case of Glamox
September 17, 1030-1200
In this class we will study the transformation, using IT, of a
traditional value chain company, the Norwegian industrial light
producer Glamox.
Read and be prepared to
discuss:
Study questions
- What were the processes of ordering from Glamox before the
redesign of the value chain? How did they change, and what effect did
the changes have on the role of the salesperson?
- What is a SPOC? What are the responsibilities of
the SPOC? What technologies
and information is required to run a SPOC?
- What are the differences between the
“standard” way of producing lamp fixtures,
and the new, componentized process in terms of
1. lot size (how many units it is economically feasible to
produce
2. reset time (how long time it takes from switching from one
product to another)
3. design (where is design and product innovation applied)
4. management (what are the salient management parameters to
consider)
5. long-term market position?
- In terms of Venkatraman’s article, which stage is
the
company at? Are all the parts of the company at the same
stage? Which parts are leading and which are lagging,and why?
- At the end of the case, what should Christian Thommessen do?
Class 5: Building a
consulting
company on open source, September 23rd, 0900-1030
Guest lecturer Trond Heier, CEO, Linpro
AS
Linpro is a consulting and development company based on the Linux
operating system and open source code. The company currently has more
than 100
employees and has been involved in a number of interesting
developments, effectively establishing open source as a viable software
alternative for many companies in Norway. Trond Heier has extensive
experience from developing
growth companies, having been CEO of Intermedia Invest A/S and VP of
international markets for Software Innovation ASA. He has a M.Sc. in
Engineering from NTH and an MBA fra Insead.
Trond will discuss two issues: How to manage and grow a small,
technical consulting company, and how to market open source technology,
particularly to larger clients.
Read and be prepared to discuss:
- Eric Raymond (1998): The Cathedral and the Bazaar, First Monday 3.3
(incidentally, a very interesting journal in its own right. Eric has
evolved this article and others into a book, and continues to evolve it.)
- Greiner, L. E. (1972). "Evolution and Revolution as
Organizations Grow." Harvard
Business Review (July-August): 37-46.
- Chapter 12 from Cringely, R. X. (1992). Accidental Empires: How the boys
of Silicon Valley make their millions, battle foreign competition, and
still can't get a date. Harmonsworth, Middlesex, England,
Penguin Books.
Class 6: IT in Value
Shops, September 23, 1030-1200
Value Shops - companies that solve problems on behalf of
customers -
exhibit their own peculiarities in value processes and IT systems - and
require their own kind of IT management.
Read and be prepared to discuss:
- Chapter 12 in P&S, including the McKinsey case
study towards the end.
- Hansen, M., N. Nohria, et al. (1999). “What is
your strategy for managing knowledge?” Harvard
Business Review (March-April): 106-116.
- Nonaka, I. (1991). “The Knowledge-Creating
Company.” Harvard Business Review
(November-December): 96-104.
- Kankanhalli, A., F. Tanudidjaja, et al. (2003). "The Role
of IT in Successful Knowledge Management Initiatives." Communications
of the ACM 46(9): 69-73.
- Carr, N. G. (2003). "IT Doesn't Matter." Harvard
Business Review (May): 41-49.
- Various responses to Carr's article, HBR Online.
Further reading:
In your spare time:
- Caves, R. E. (2000). Creative
Industries: Contracts Between Art and Commerce.
Cambridge, MA, Harvard University Press. Excellent history of
contracting and art: Lays out the peculiar reward and work mechanisms
for writers, actors, painters, movie people, musicians as a consequence
of the economic properties of creative products and their
consumption. Good economic history of the movie, music and
theatre industries, as well.
Study questions:
- What purposes does information technology serve in a Value
Shop organization?
- What are the differences between McKinsey and Andersen
Consulting in their use of information technology? Why?
- How do information systems in a Value Chain differ from
those in a Value Shop?
- What obstacles do you think you will face when implementing
knowledge system in a stockbroking company? A
hospital? A
law firm?
Class
7/8: IT in Value Networks
October 1, 0900-1200
Value networks - companies that mediate interaction between customers -
tend to have interesting IT use. We will review some well known cases
of strategic use of information technology in value networks,
specifically the case of American
Airlines, famous for its SABRE
system, and the case of Pacific Pride -- a less known, but not less
interesting example of IT in networks.
Read
and be prepared to discuss:
- Hopper,
M. D. (1990). Rattling SABRE--New Ways to Compete on
Information. Harvard
Business Review (May-June), 118-125.
- Copeland, D. G., & McKenney, J. L. (1988). Airline
Reservations Systems: Lessons from History. MIS Quarterly
(September), 353-370. (We will talk about the competitive benefits of
SABRE, as outlined here.)
- Davis, Paul (1994) Airline
Ties Profitability Yield to Management SIAM News, Vol.
27, No. 5 (if the link is unreliable, try the PDF version in
Blackboard.)
- Hormer, Peter (2000): The
SABRE Story: The making of OR magic at AMR, OR/MS
Today.
- Here is a good newspaper article on the more recent airline
situation: Flight
into the red, St.Petersburg
Times, 2003.
- Case: Pacific Pride Services, Inc. This
is an old case - but think, what if they were a mobile phone company?
Further reading (for the especially interested):
- Smith, B. C., J. F. Leimkuhler, et al. (1992). "Yield
Management at American Airlines." Interfaces 22(1):
8-31. Excellent article on how yield management works - and
the impact it had on American Airlines.
- Andersen, E. and Ø. Fjeldstad (2003).
"Understanding
inter-firm relations in mediation industries with special reference to
the Nordic Mobile Communication Industry." Industrial
Marketing Management 32: 397-408.
- McKenney, J. L. (1995). Waves
of Change: Business Evolution through Information Technology.
Boston, MA, Harvard Business School Press. The "big cases" of
IT
as competitive weapon (Bank of America, American Airlines, Frito-Lay,
USAA and American Hospital Supply).
- Petzinger, T. (1996). Hard
Landing.
New York, Times Business Books. The play-by-play of the US
(and
trans-Atlantic) airline industry since it was deregulated in
1980. Great fun, gunslingers at OK Corral style.
In your spare time:
- Gladwell, M. (2000). The
Tipping Point.
London, Abacus. A lighthearted book on how fashions and
epidemics
get started and spread - and with lots of examples that help you
understand network economics without using economics or (too many)
sociology terms.
Assignment (to be delivered in Blackboard):
What benefits has American Airlines derived from its SABRE computerized
reservations system from the 1950's to the 1990's?
Study questions:
- What are the economic characteristics of an airline?
- What are the similarities, in terms of the competitive
dynamics
and IT use, between the telecommunications industry, airlines, and
banks?
- (this one is tricky) How valuable are Pacific Pride's
information systems?
- Who was John von Neumann? What is the "von
Neumann principle"?
Class 9: Managing
IT as a service (lecture)
October 8, 0900-1030
This class will be a lecture introducing the concept of IT management
as running a business within the business, necessitating the
development of a service-centric IT organization with roles
and
interfaces defined and designed according to the IT demand and supply
maturity of the organization. The following report is background
reading:
- The Concours Group (2004): Service-centric IT,
Re.sults report SIT.
Class 10/11: Managing
IT Economics, Oct 13, 1300-1600
The economics of investing in and using information
technology: One
of the hardest problems of managing IT is deciding on how much to spend
on IT and understanding what the economic effect of the investment
is. We will look at this topic both from the viewpoint of a
single company and by examining data from many companies.
Read and be prepared to discuss:
- Chapter 4 and 10 in P&S.
- Hitt, L., & Brynjolfsson, E. (1996). Productivity,
Business
Profitability, and Consumer Surplus: Three Different Measures of
Information Technology Value. MIS Quarterly, 20(2),
121-142.
- The InformationWEEK 500, InformationWEEK,
September 1995.
I suggest you try to analyze one particular industry, for instance
Aerospace, Banking or Telecommunications, and then look at the bigger
chart (or spreadsheet)
to compare across industries.
- David, P. A. (1985). Clio and the Economics of QWERTY. American Economic Review,
75 (May-June), 332-337. (For an alternative view on this, check out
Liebowitz, S. and S. Margolis (1990). "The
Fable of the Keys." The Journal of Law and Economics
(April) as well as this page
on the fable of the fable.
- Volkswagen of America: Managing IT Priorities
(HBS ref. 9-606-003).
Further reading for the specially interested:
- Gerlach, J., B. Neumann, et al. (2002). "Determining the
Cost of IT Services." Communications of the ACM 45(9):
61-67.
- Shapiro, C. and H.R. Varian (1999): Information
Rules: A Strategic Guide to the Network Economy.
Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press. (Excellent
book on the economics of information and software, check out their web site.)
- Zuboff, S. (1988). In
the Age of the Smart Machine: The Future of Work and Power.
New York, Basic Books. Sophisticated, if long, discussion of
the
effects of information technology on work and power in traditional
organizations. Antidote to most e-books, coined the term
"informate" (as opposed to "automate.")
Assignment (to be delivered in Blackboard, individually. NOTE: Deliver this not in the digital dropbox, but in the assignment under the Assignments heading.):
Imagine you are a CEO worrying about whether you are spending too much
or not enough on information technology. How would the InformationWEEK
500 study help you? For help with the analysis, here's an Excel worksheet with the numbers.
Use Shift-click to download the file to your own computer, then analyze
it there using Excel or another spreadsheet. (Note: Max. two pages,
including everything. The shorter the better... Note also that since
the article is from 1995, the technological discussions are rather
dated - read them less as gospel and more as genre.)
Study questions:
- Why did white-collar productivity not increase as much as
blue-collar productivity in the period 1985-95?
- What are Hitt & Brynjolfsson's three measures of
information technology profitability -- and their conclusions about
them?
- How do you justify spending money on upgrading desktop
computers and increasing Internet bandwidth?
- What is your assessment of the new process for managing IT
priorities at VWoA?
- How should Uwe Matulovic respond to his fellow
executives who are calling
to ask him for special treatment outside the new priority management
system?
- What should he do about the unfunded Supply Flow project?
- Who was Doug Engelbart? What is "bootstrapping"?
Class
12/13: Managing IT-business boundaries -- outsourcing and IT
leadership, Oct 16, 0900-1200
The functional management of IT is tricky, involving both
operational excellence, managing technology employees, managing
customer expectations and dealing with a multitude of vendors and
consultants. As with most management issues, we learn the most when we
study things that don't work well....
Read and be prepared to discuss:
- Chapter 9 in P&S.
- Earl, M. and D. F. Feeny (1994). “Is your CIO
adding value?” Sloan Management Review
(Spring): 11-20.
- Hagel, J. and J. S. Brown (2001). "Your Next IT Strategy." Harvard Business Review (October):
105-113.
- Amoribieta, I., K. Bhaumik, et al. (2001). "Programmers abroad: A
primer on offshore software development." McKinsey Quarterly(2):
128-140.
- Auguste, B. G., Y. Hao, et al. (2003). "The other side of outsourcing." McKinsey Quarterly(1): 52-64.
- Dignan, L. (2003). "Leaping, then looking."
Baseline (September):
17-29. Short discussion of the economic and competitive
implications "offshoring" and the gradual emergence of a global job
market for technology workers.
- DiRomualdo, A. and V. Gurbaxani (1998). "Strategic Intent
for IT Outsourcing."
Sloan Management Review 39(4): 67-80.
- This great article from Wired on various
sides of outsourcing to India.
- Case: Hostile
IS outsourcing: The story of ManuFact
- Case: Lean at Wipro Technologies, HBS 9-607-032
Further reading for the specially interested:
- Ross, J. W. (2003). Creating
a Strategic IT Architecture Competency: Learning in Stages.
CISR working paper 335. Cambridge, Massachusetts MIT.
- McFarlan, F. W.,& Nolan, R. L. (1995). How to
Manage an IT Outsourcing Alliance. Sloan Management Review
(Winter), 9-23. Managerially oriented article on outsourcing,
explaining financials and the effect of Kodak.
- Lacity, M. C., & Hirschheim, R. (1993). The
Information Systems Outsourcing Bandwagon. Sloan Management
Review (Fall), 73-86. A slightly more skeptical
look at outsourcing.
- Andersen, E. (2002). "Stamp
Out Technology Virginity!" ACM Ubiquity
3(30).
Assignment (to be delivered in Blackboard - individually, and in Safeassignment, before 20:00 October 15.):
Who is responsible for the Manufact situation? Should John Smith take
the offer from Jim Lawler? If he takes the offer, what conditions
should he set? (Maximum 400 words).
Study questions (more to come):
- Why has outsourcing become so popular?
- What is XML? Why is it considered such an important
technology by Hagel and Brown?
- Who was Stephen Wozniak -- and what was it that was
"insanely great?"
Class 14: Managing
IT development and delivery, Monday Oct. 20, 1030-1200
How should development projects be managed? We will discuss
a systems development project (CONFIRM) that failed.
Read
and be prepared to discuss:
- Chapters 6 and 11 in P&S.
- "The Collapse of CONFIRM: What went wrong?", p. 534 in
Laudon & Laudon: Management Information Systems,
Fourth edition, Prentice-Hall, 1996.
- Oz, E. (1994). When Professional Standards are Lax: The
CONFIRM Failure and its Lessons. Communications of the ACM,
37(10), 29-36.
- Hopper,
M. D. (1990). Rattling SABRE--New Ways to Compete on
Information. Harvard
Business Review (May-June), 118-125. (already
assigned for session 5/6, use in conjunction with Oz to evaluate
CONFIRM.)
Further reading (for the specially interested):
- Wheelwright, S. C. and K. B. Clark (1992).
“Creating Project Plans to Focus Product
Development.” Harvard Business Review (March-April):
2-14.
- Rich, B. R. and L. Janos (1994). Skunk
Works.
New York: Little, Brown. (The history of Lockheed Martin's
"skunk
works," a highly innovative - and colorful - group of engineers who
developed the U2
spy plane, the SR-71 Blackbird,
and Stealth
technology.)
- Brand,
Stewart (1995). How
Buildings Learn.
New York, Penguin Books. (Great book on what makes some
buildings
great for living in--rather than just looking at. A
technology
book -- about houses)
- Norman, D. A.
(1988). The
Psychology of Everyday Things. New York, Basic
Books. Fun on user-centered design -- and why door-handles with words
on them are signs of design failure...
Study questions:
- Why did the CONFIRM project fail? (Consider technical,
organizational and strategic reasons.)
- Why is it hard to get people to work in IT departments?
- Who was Frederick Brooks? What is a "man month"
and what is its significance with respect to project management?
Class 15/16: Understanding
technology in your life and society, Oct. 23rd,
0900-1200
Enterprise search technology: Davor Sutija, FAST
Society, ethics and the individual in a digital world.
Read and be prepared to discuss:
- Chapter 8 in P&S.
- Turing,
A. M. (1949). “Computer
Machinery and Intelligence.” Mind
59(236): 433-460.
- Check out this
link (turn on the sound first).
- While you are at it, look up search technology in
Wikipedia. As well as "web services" and "XML".
- Andersen, E. (2002). "Attendre
le Suitcase..." ACM Ubiquity 3(7).
- Andersen, E. (2003). "Genesis
of an anthill: Wireless technology and self-organizing systems."
Ubiquity 3(49).
- Bower, J. L., & Christensen, C. C. (1995).
Disruptive Technologies: Catching the Waves. Harvard Business
Review (January-February), 43-53. (For
more details on the disk drive industry, Chapter 1 of The
Innovator's Dilemma can be found here).
- Christensen, C. M., M. Raynor, et al. (2001). "Skate to
Where the Money Will Be." Harvard
Business Review (November): 73-81.
- Revisit David's article on the QWERTY keyboard previous
classes, including the rebuttal,
and re-rebuttal.
Further reading (for the especially interested).
Yes, I know I went off the deep end here, but you
need something to occupy you when this course is over.:
- Stephenson, Neal (1999). In
the beginning ... was the command line. (available
for free from various places on the Internet, including Stephenson's web site.)
A great "extended essay" on how technology, espcially information
technology, has evolved and will evolve in the future. Explores the
levels at which we understand technology and how we forge our
relationship with it.
- Hofstadter, D. M. (1979). Gödel,
Esher, Bach: An Eternal Golden Braid.
New York, Vintage Books. (Wonderful book on computers, music,
art, mathematics and most of all--self-referential systems.)
- Bolter, J. D. (1984). Turings
Man: Western Culture in the Computer Age.
Old Woking, Surrey, UK, Unwin Brothers Ltd. (Man always seen
himself in terms of the technology of the times--and now the technology
is the computer)
- Dennett, D. C. (1991). Consciousness
Explained. Boston, MA, Little, Brown &
Co. (What is consciousness--and where in the brain does it
reside?)
- Lessig, L. (2001). The
Future of Ideas: The Fate of the Commons in a Connected World.
New York, Random House. Brilliantly written on the connection
between copyright and innovation - and the need to have "commons" where
innovation can take place.
- Garfinkel, S. L. (2000). Database
Nation: The Death of Privacy in the 21st Century.
Sebastopol, CA, O'Reilly and Associates, Inc. How technology
intrudes -- and what you can do about it (more of the former than the
latter.)
- Hafner, K. and M. Lyon (1996). Where
Wizards Stay Up Late: The Origins of the Internet.
New York, Simon & Schuster. Good history of the
Internet.
- Hafner, K. and J. Markoff (1991). Cyberpunk:
Outlaws and Hackers on the Computer Frontier. New
York, Simon & Schuster. Good book on computer
sabotage and why people do it.
Study questions:
- What is a disruptive technology? Why do existing,
dominant companies often fail to respond to it?
- When was the (computer) mouse invented, and by whom?
- How about the graphical user interface (GUI) with windows
(sometimes called WIMP interface)? The laser printer?
- How does thinking about privacy differ between Europe and
the United States?
- Within our lifetimes, computers that are smarter than
people will
not only be possible, but common. Agree or diagree?
Why?
- Check out www.archive.org. What
does the site do? Is this necessary?
- What is the Turing test? Do you think we can create a
machine that can pass it? Would that be a thinking
machine?
- Who is Bill Joy? What is Java?
Class 17/18: Final
lecture, October 30 9-12, the groups present their case solution to the
final case.
- each group develops a paper and a presentation, hands the paper in and presents to the class
- you are supposed to act like a consulting company when you do it, presenting your solution to the challenges
- (but no need to put on suits and all that)
- Each presentation will get 5-7 minutes, followed by questions
from the class (acting as the top management team of the case company),
followed by an evaluation of the presentation by students and instructor
NSM's home page
Espen Andersen's
home page
Comments to 